Medical condition claims life of former Yale police chief

YALE — Yale community members who knew former Police Chief Brian Mahaffy were stunned and saddened to learn of his passing over Halloween weekend.

Mahaffy suffered a brain aneurysm while hunting, according to a Facebook post shared by his wife, Jill.

He died Nov. 4 as a result of the medical emergency.

After many years in law enforcement with the city of St. Clair, Mahaffy retired and pursued a degree in criminal justice. He worked in Yale as an officer and was named the city’s chief in 2017.

Also a former St. Clair Township supervisor, Mahaffy attended St. Clair County Community College in Port Huron after graduating from high school in 1982. He said at the time that he “enjoyed the convenience of a college close to my hometown of Peck and liked the criminal justice program they offered.”

After serving four years as an officer in Houston, Mahaffy returned to St. Clair, Michigan, and served with the department until 2014 as a sergeant. He was hired by the city of Yale as a school liaison officer in 2015 before becoming police chief in 2017.

Former Yale Mayor Dick Busch said he knew Mahaffy was special and someone he wanted to see serving Yale as chief.

“I bumped into Brian at a party store one night,” Busch recalled. “After the previous chief left the department, I asked him if he would like to be the next chief in Yale and he said sure. So, I appointed him at the next council meeting. He was well-liked at the school. I would say of the four police chiefs that served during my time on council, Brian by far was the best chief Yale has ever had.”

Busch said Mahaffy was “a great man and very fair to everyone. He was well loved in Yale and always had time to talk with you. He would do anything you asked him to. His passing is such a tragedy, so sad. My thoughts are with his family.”

That sense of loss resonated across the community, shared by those who worked alongside Mahaffy in town leadership and local media.

“It was with great sadness I heard of former Chief Brian Mahaffy’s accident while hunting and his passing. I had the pleasure of working with Brian on many occasions,” said Barbara Brown-Stasik, formerly of The Expositor and the Chamber of Commerce.

“When we brought the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Moving Wall to Yale, Brian and I worked closely together to bring our community an event that we would never forget. His enthusiasm and support meant so very much,” she said.

“When Yale had events or parades, Chief Brian was always extremely helpful and supportive of anything positive in our community. We had many great years of working together and I will forever be thankful for his friendship, efforts and positive attitude for his job and the Yale community as a whole. He was a complete class act, and we were so blessed to call him a friend.”

That same warmth, humor, and integrity left a lasting impression on everyone who knew him away from the uniform.

“Everyone loved Brian,” said Scot Sheldon, a former brother-in-law and previous owner of Sheldon Pharmacy. “He was an amazing guy that brought humor and common sense to any situation. As my brother-in-law and a close friend for many years, I was lucky to have so much time and fun with him. He will be missed!”

That deep affection and sense of loss echoed across his entire family, finding its most poignant voice at home.

“In a way that feels so fitting for Brian, he spent his final moments peacefully, surrounded by the beautiful fall leaves, in the place he loved most,” Jill Mahaffy shared, finding comfort that he was doing what he loved despite the family’s grief.

That profound love, she noted, will endure through the countless lives he touched. She reflected on his generosity, unmistakable humor, and famous knack for telling tall tales, emphasizing his rare gift for making everyone feel valued and deeply loved.

As the family navigates the difficult days ahead, they are drawing strength from faith, community support, and the memories he left behind. Jill expressed deep gratitude for the meals, prayers and stories pouring in, promising that their family will keep his spirit alive by continuing to share his adventures and love one another just as he did.

“Until we meet again, Brian,” she closed. “We love you beyond words.”